1 / 3 sider - klik for at bladre

Organdonation: Etiske og lovgivningsmæssige perspektiver

  • Engelsk
  • 2.g el. lign.
  • Afleveret til 12
  • 3 sider PDF

Det er gratis at oprette en konto

Organdonation: Etiske og lovgivningsmæssige perspektiver er en engelsk-opgave til 2.g el. lign., afleveret til karakteren 12. Fylder 3 sider (998 ord, ca. 4 min. læsning) og blev publiceret 29. november 2014.

Analysen af fire engelsksprogede tekster om organdonation, herunder Nigel Hawkes, Jane E. Brody, The Economist og Joost Van Egmond, undersøger forskellige perspektiver på emnet. Den diskuterer etiske dilemmaer, lovgivningsmæssige tilgange som formodet samtykke og legalisering af nyrehandel, samt mediernes rolle i at øge opmærksomheden. Opgaven inkluderer også personlige refleksioner.

Redaktørens vurdering
10 Fortrinlig
Solid analyse af fire tekster om organdonation med diskussion af etiske og lovgivningsmæssige aspekter. Velfunderet og struktureret.
Struktur
10
Faglig dybde
10
Kilder
10
Fuldstændighed
10
  • etik
  • formodet samtykke
  • holland
  • lovgivning
  • medier
  • nyrehandel
  • organdonation
  • spanien
  • storbritannien
  • sundhedspolitik

Nigel Hawkes writes in the first text that the government should assume everyone as an organ donor, unless he or she personally opts out. It is necessary because of an ever increasing demand of replacement organs. Instead of organ donors having to register themselves, everyone should be assumed as a donor. The reason is that even though many people support organ donations, only a few actually donate themselves. The amount of people in need of organs has been the highest ever. Furthermore the amount of donors does not increase much. People die because of waiting. Dead people, whose lives could have been extended by organ donations. Furthermore Hawkes points out that Britain is far behind other developed countries, like Spain, regarding the number of donors. This is because Spain has assumed to begin with that everybody is a donor. If a system like the Spanish one would be introduced in Britain, everybody would be respected, Hawkes underlines. Those who do not wish to donate their organs can easily just opt out. Three years ago the government rejected a donation law, but today they are considering it again. At last Hawkes gives us an example of a young woman, who has suffered a brain haemorrhage. Her parents decide to donate her organs. Later on grateful patients thank the parents, which makes them feel better. They believe that people should reconsider before rejecting the donation. Yet it is very difficult for a deceased’s family. Everybody should therefore not be assumed a donor according to the young woman’s mother.

Få adgang til denne og 100.000+ andre opgaver i PDF

Det er gratis at oprette en konto

Du har også set på

Lignende opgaver